Banavie

Banavie | Ben Nevis from Banavie - Then and now

For a year, photographer and history researcher Estelle Slegers Helsen has wandered around Lochaber in the footsteps of W.S. Thomson MBE (1906-1967). Estelle has made a series of remakes roughly 70 years after Thomson originally depicted the landscape. She has talked to local people along her journey and now regularly Estelle will be taking you to a different place in Lochaber. This is article #3.

Ben Nevis from Banavie

Banavie | Ben Nevis from Banavie - Then and now

Ronald Cameron from Banavie guides me up the southeast slope of Meall Bhanbhaidh, a 327-metre hill, to find where W.S. Thomson planted his tripod for his early 1950s colour photograph Ben Nevis from Banavie.

This photograph was printed as a two-page spread in Thomson’s second full-colour pictorial book Colourful Scotland, published in 1956 by Oliver and Boyd, based in Edinburgh.

The picture’s view jogs Ronald’s memory. “I was 12 when I first climbed Ben Nevis with Alastair, Thomson’s son. Our route took us via the climber’s hut underneath the north face and round the back,” explains Ronald. “At that time, Alastair was 18 and extremely fit, doing this as a favour to my father, because I was a rather fat teenager in need of a wake-up call.”

Thomson and his wife Elizabeth (née Frame) had two children: Alastair, born in 1941 in Kirkwall, Orkney, and Fiona, born in 1944 near Glasgow. As part of my ongoing research into W.S. Thomson, I know that Alastair joined the Royal Air Force and married Gwyneth Johns in 1964.

Ronald continues: “I have a shadowy memory of Thomson taking my picture twice as a young child in his studio in Corpach.” Alas, these photographs are nowhere to be found.

When my camera is in position for a remake, light-grey clouds still cover the UK’s highest mountain, so we have plenty of time for a chat.

2022
2022
2022
Early 1950s
Early 1950s

Move the slider to discover what changed.

Then (left) – Early 1950s © W.S. Thomson – Ben Nevis from Banavie. Published in Colourful Scotland (1956), p.32-33.
Now (right) – June 2022 © Estelle Slegers Helsen – Ben Nevis from Banavie.

With one eye on the landscape and the other on the book, Ronald points his finger to the left of the old picture, adding: “Alastair and I first followed the track along the Allt a’ Mhuillinn, the small stream between the flank of Càrn Mòr Dearg and the north face of Ben Nevis.”

We see the mountain’s north face in profile from front to back: Castle Ridge, Tower Ridge, Observatory Ridge and Northeast Buttress are easy scrambles for good climbers in summer, then often climbed solo or unroped. In winter, they are much more demanding. “While I have climbed all the buttresses listed I have never climbed any of them entirely unroped. I have never crossed Tower Gap unroped,” says Ronald.

In the centre of Thomson’s photograph, on the left, just beneath the stitches of the pages, is a whitewashed farm. “That is Allt Mòr (Aultmore), or big burn, named after the nearby stream, where my great-grandmother Catherine Cameron (1843-1908) came from. She married a widower, Robert Pringle, who had 2 children. They had 3 children and when he died early she returned to Fort William with all 5 children.”

Full of nostalgia, Ronald continues: “When I was a child, I spent a lot of time at Allt Mòr with my father’s relatives. I learned to milk cows, drive the tractor and make hay.”

The farm, after all these years in ruin, because it was abandoned and the old house was burned down by vandals a couple of weeks ago, seems swallowed by trees. In the fields, which are still there, a friend of Ronald keeps sheep. Just behind the old farm runs the Caledonian Canal, and in the old picture, further to the right, we can see a bend in the River Lochy. The picture also features the ever-visible pipelines for the Lochaber aluminium plant hydro scheme.

Seventy years on, the valley and the lower slope of Ben Nevis is almost completely covered in trees, partly Forestry Commission pine wood plantations for timber and partly regeneration woodland with a mix of conifers and deciduous trees. “In a way, more tree cover is good,” says Ronald, “because we are getting red squirrels moving back, which weren’t here when I was a child.”

On the hill where we are standing, full-grown birch trees obstruct the view of the single-track road from Banavie to Gairlochy, as you can see in the bottom part of Thomson’s image, which he took in early spring.

More than 60 years after his first ascent of Ben Nevis, which turned him into a sporty young man, Ronald, now 75, has to leave for an early evening canoeing adventure on the River Orchy.

During this pleasant day in early June, I stay for another few hours because blue patches slowly arrive from the southwest, suffusing the broad landscape with softer late afternoon sunlight.



Logos West Highland Museum, Year of Stories 2022, Heritage Fund, Museums Galleries Scotland and EventScotland

Travel in Time – Lochaber Series is supported by the West Highland Museum and the Year of Stories 2022 Community Stories Fund.

Estelle has published a 64-page book with 30 side-by-side then-and-now pictures, which you can find in local shops or buy online. More information available here.

, ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *