Corpach

Corpach | Tombuie - Then and now

Photographer and historical researcher Estelle Slegers Helsen has been wandering around Lochaber in the footsteps of the Scottish photographer W.S. Thomson MBE (1906-1967). Since 2021, she has taken photographic remakes for roughly 75 years after Thomson initially captured the landscape and has talked to local people along her journey. This is article #24.

Corpach | Tombuie - Then and now

In the early 1950s, W.S. Thomson took the photograph Winter sun and hoar frost above Corpach, Ben Nevis in the distance, which was published in his pictorial book Colourful Scotland (1956). He already lived in Corpach, settling in Kilmallie House in 1951 after having lived on Cameron Square in Fort William for six years.

Being familiar with the location, he probably ran up to Tombuie, knowing the hoar frost was perfect for an outstanding photo. Hoar frost is a godsend for photographers. This meteorological phenomenon creates a magical world of objects covered with crystal-clear ice against a bright blue sky. The winter wonderland continues for as long as the temperature remains well below zero.

It was at the end of October 2021, and this image was the first in a series of remakes taken over the next few years in Lochaber. I only had a vague idea of where to go and parked my car on Drumfada Terrace. This was a challenge as I was still learning the technique of retracing places. New to the area, and with only a scattering of preliminary research, it was like looking for a needle in a haystack.

I scrambled for more than an hour in the fields above the cemetery and the surrounding area, ending up in a muddy field near the back garden of a house. The owner, who was creating a ditch with an oversized digger on an adjacent track, looked surprised and asked where I came from. Luckily, this is Scotland. In England, people would not be amused. I apologised and explained the purpose of my journey.

While both looking at the satellite map on my phone, we discovered a vague outline of a long-abandoned cottage. It could be the one I was looking for. We then discussed how I might reach the location.

About an hour later, I found a ruin. It was Tombuie with the birch tree still there 70 years later.

Corpach - Tombuie
Corpach - Tombuie

Overexcited, I took a few remakes, but the light wasn’t great.

Corpach - Tombuie

I packed my gear and decided to return in a few days. On my way down, I said hello to a man on a quad bike inspecting Shetland sheep.

In the evening, I posted the then-and-now photos on the Fort William Memories Facebook page, and Jean Sneddon contacted me the next day.

‘I am so sad to see the gable end has come down. It is many years since I was up there as I’m not as able anymore,’ says Jean. ‘My grandfather Dugald Macintyre was the local shepherd and lived in Tombuie until the late 1950s when he moved to one of the new houses on Drumfada Road.’ Sometimes, social media is a handy tool.

The face of Corpach changed rapidly in the 1950s and 60s because of the development of a paper mill, which, at its peak in the 1970s, employed over 900 people. Corpach, A’ Chorpaich in Gaelic, means ‘field of the death’ and is thought to originate from it being a resting place on the coffin road used to carry chieftains for burial on Iona.

Jean continues: ‘I am sure W.S. Thomson photographed my grandfather while herding a couple of cows up the hill at Corpach, just above Kilmallie Parish Church. My parents had it framed and hung in their living room. It is lost now and I have been looking for it ever since.’

Over the next few days, as I ask about the landowner, I am referred to Maisie MacPhee, who welcomes me to her house opposite the land leading to Tombuie. Her husband, John, who joins the conversation, recognises me from a week ago when I was walking down the hill. ‘I was the man on the quad bike,’ he says, smiling.

Maisie has many stories but doesn’t remember Dugald Macintyre living in Tombuie. ‘I was about three years old when he moved to Drumfada Terrace. I remember visiting the place; it was empty but still had a roof. The building was deteriorating fairly quickly and vandalism had its part to play.’

I conclude my first ten-day journey in early November 2021, in the Fort William area, with another remake at Tombuie. The path, shown on a late 19th-century Ordnance Survey map, starting from the main road opposite Corpach Hotel, has long disappeared. Houses have been built on much of the land.

Corpach | Tombuie - Map NLS
Corpach and Tombuie – OS Map Inverness-shire – Mainland Sheet CXXXIX – Date revised: 1899, Date published: 1903 – Collection National Library of Scotland – CC-BY (NLS)

Instead, I take the gates from the main road opposite Maisie’s house. Their Shetland sheep follow me as I ramble uphill. In Thomson’s old photograph, chickens are part of the scenery. I hope to include some sheep in my remake. But by the time my camera is in place and the light is good, the sheep have lost interest and are nibbling grass further away. At least the birch tree is still there. If that tree could talk, I would have the whole story…

(Read further after the images)

November 2021
November 2021
November 2021
Early 1950s
Early 1950s

Move the slider to discover what changed.

Then (left) – Early 1950s © W.S. Thomson – Winter sun and hoar frost above Corpach, Ben Nevis in the distance. Published in Colourful Scotland (Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh, 1956), p. 42.

Now (right) – November 2021 © Estelle Slegers Helsen – The remains of Tombuie above Corpach, Ben Nevis in the distance. Published in Travel in Time. Lochaber, Scotland (New Traces, Waltham on the Wolds, 2022), p. 17.

In 2022, Jean messaged me the photo of her grandfather herding two cows on the hill with Corpach and Loch Linnhe in the background.

Douglas Macintyre herding his cows to Tombuie © W. S. Thomson - Collection Jean Sneddon
Dugald Macintyre herding his cows to Tombuie © W. S. Thomson – Collection Jean Sneddon


Logos West Highland Museum, Year of Stories 2022, Heritage Fund, Museums Galleries Scotland and EventScotland

Travel in Time – Lochaber Series is supported by the West Highland Museum and the Year of Stories 2022 Community Stories Fund.

Estelle has published a 64-page book with 30 side-by-side then-and-now pictures, which you can find in local shops or buy online. More information available here.

Travel in Time - Lochaber - Cover
, ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *