Ardtoe

Rhum and Eigg from Ardtoe, Acharacle - Then and now

For a year, photographer and history researcher Estelle Slegers Helsen has wandered around Lochaber in the footsteps of W.S. Thomson MBE (1906-1967). Estelle has made a series of remakes roughly 70 years after Thomson originally depicted the landscape. She has talked to local people along her journey and now Estelle will be taking you to the different places in Lochaber. This is article #4.

Rhum and Eigg from Ardtoe

Rhum and Eigg from Ardtoe, Acharacle - Then and now

When still living in Belgium and working as a journalist for radio and television, I once made a series for the weekly radio programme entitled ‘The End of the World’. The small community of Ardtoe (Àird Tobha), tucked away on the coast of Ardnamurchan, would be a perfect spot for a topic in this programme.

When driving from Acharacle on the single-track road through the flat landscape of Kentra Moss and passing Kentra Bay at the jetty of Ardtoe, I try to imagine the condition of this road more than 70 years ago. Up to 1951, the metalled road ended at the jetty near Pier Cottage. Turning sharply to the right, it continued as a rocky path among volcanic hills, reaching Ardtoe a mile further on, now with a view of the open sea.

W.S. Thomson visited the fishing hamlet of Ardtoe several times. Preparing this then-and-now series, I came across two colour photographs taken five to ten years apart from the same volcanic rock formation, Tòrr a’ Linntean, but from a slightly different angle.

During my first visit on June 12th [2022], I meet Hugh Macpherson, who has lived in Ardtoe his whole life, just like his ancestors up to the end of the 1700s. ‘For centuries, there has been a strong community of Macnaughtons, Camerons, Macphersons, as well as an Irish family of Nisbets,’ explains Hugh when I ask him who lived in the houses featured in the old colour pictures.

When I ask for the least challenging way to tackle the steep hill, Hugh shrugs, saying he hasn’t been up for years. ‘It is all covered in trees now. In the 1970s, when I was a kid, there were just rocks.’

Although the sky is covered in cloud, at my first attempt scrambling through bracken, scrub and a lot of rotten birch trees, I reach a platform for a few remakes. It is close, but not close enough.

Rum and Eigg from Ardtoe | Then and now
Then – Early 1960s – © W. S. Thomson – Rum and Eigg from Ardtoe. Published in Beauty Spots of Argyll (Early 1960s). Edinburgh, Wm. S. Thomson (Colour Photographs) Ltd), plate no. 2 Now – June 2022 – © Estelle Slegers Helsen – Rum and Eigg from Ardtoe

When returning a week later, on June 19th [2022], I first pitch my tent at the campsite run by Hugh. Then after the climb, often getting stuck again in the deep black bog in my wellies, I take another series. Again there is no perfect match.

Rum and Eigg from Ardtoe | Then and now
Then – Early 1960s – © W. S. Thomson – Rum and Eigg from Ardtoe. Published in Beauty Spots of Argyll (Early 1960s). Edinburgh, Wm. S. Thomson (Colour Photographs) Ltd), plate no. 2 Now – June 2022 – © Estelle Slegers Helsen – Rum and Eigg from Ardtoe

Back at the campsite, Hugh gives me a folder of about 40 pages, entitled ‘My Treasured Memories of Being a Macpherson of Ardtoe’. It is the family history typed up by Hugh’s aunt, Mary Macphee (née Macpherson), dated September 2004, richly illustrated with photocopies of family pictures. What a treasure!

And, to my surprise, there is even one of W.S. Thomson’s postcards, which Mary dated pre-1955.

The Islands of Rum and Eigg from Ardtoe, near Acharacle in the Ardnamurchan Peninsula, Argyll-shire, Scotland
The Islands of Rhum and Eigg from Ardtoe, near Acharacle in the Ardnamurchan peninsula, Argyll-shire, Scotland. Colour Photograph by W. S. Thomson, Fort William. Published as a postcard #3486 – Printed and Published by j.Arthur Dixon, Ltd.

The photograph is taken from the west flank of the volcanic rock, also depicting a view of a handful of houses, the beaches, the isles of Eigg and Rum and, as an added extra, a young man, a ‘kiltie’ wearing a black and blue tartan kilt.

The postcard jogged Mary’s memories, and she wrote: ‘This is the Ardtoe that I remember best, green fields with hay stacks, calm seas with the islands of Eigg and Rum in the distance. The tide is in at Sàilean Dubh, and Port Ban looks so clean and white. The hay is all neatly in stacks and fields of potatoes, ready for digging. The fields all look so well cared for.’

Diary Mary Macpherson - September 2004
Diary Mary Macpherson – September 2004

The house on the left is the family home of the Macphersons, and the one in the bottom right belongs to the Camerons. Both families gradually upgraded the dwellings, which they still own today. The ruin to the left of the building with the red corrugated iron roof was where the Nisbets lived. Like all houses in Ardtoe, it was a thatched croft until the 1920s.

Thomson took this picture before 1951 because there is no trace of a proper path, which later became a track that went all the way to the Macphersons. In 1966 the White Fish Authority started building the Ardtoe Marine Laboratory, and the road was upgraded and extended. The facility closed in 2020. Hugh lives in the new house at the bottom left of the remake.

The new picture I have selected was taken last September when revisiting Hugh to deliver a copy of the published booklet. I invited him to join me climbing the rocky hill, but he kindly declined as he was busy working in a field adjacent to his house. A few hours and several rain showers later, I was bidding ‘The End of the World’ farewell and driving back to Acharacle.

2022
2022
2022
Late 1940s
Late 1940s

Move the slider to discover what changed.

Then (left) – End 1940s © W.S. Thomson – Rhum and Eigg from Ardtoe, Acharacle. Published in The Highlands in Colour (Oliver and Boyd, 1954), p. 38

Now (right) – September 2022 © Estelle Slegers Helsen – View of Ardtoe, Rhum and Eigg from Tor Luinngeanach.

On the National Library Scotland website, you can view a full-length video on everyday life in Acharacle, Salen and Ardtoe. The silent colour film titled In and around Acharacle is filmed by Dr. Iain Dunnachie in 1952/1953. The third part of the film displays a series of shots taken in and around Ardtoe: a woman and three children walking along the road with a view of Ardtoe Pier; a man sitting aboard a boat moored in Kentra Bay (Ardtoe Pier?), mending boards on the deck; a young man sharpens his scythe by hand, then cutting long grass, the Macpherson and Cameron crofts near the sea; women patting a cow as it eats directly from metal bucket, men in a boat on Kentra Bay; a family on a beach; shells and hermit crabs (?) in shallow water; and crabs scuttling along.

NLS - Moving Image - Archive - Screenshot Ardtoe
Source screenshot – NLD – Moving Image Archive – Reference number 9286 – In and Around Acharacle


Logos West Highland Museum, Year of Stories 2022, Heritage Fund, Museums Galleries Scotland and EventScotland

Travel in Time – Lochaber Series is supported by the West Highland Museum and the Year of Stories 2022 Community Stories Fund.

Estelle has published a 64-page book with 30 side-by-side then-and-now pictures, which you can find in local shops or buy online. More information available here.

, ,

2 responses to “Ardtoe”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *